Don't get tricked.
Appeal to authority, explained simply
A title, a uniform or a confident voice is not evidence.
An appeal to authority is when someone asks you to accept a claim because of who is saying it, and not because of the evidence. A title, a uniform or a confident voice stands in for proof.
This person is important, so what they say must be true.Who is speaking is not the same as what is true. @heykayandco
The experiment that showed it
In 1961, at Yale, psychologist Stanley Milgram told volunteers they were helping with a study on memory. A man in a gray lab coat told each volunteer to give another person an electric shock for every wrong answer, and to make each shock stronger than the last. The shocks were fake and the other person was an actor. The volunteers did not know that.
In the best-known version, 26 of the 40 volunteers, which is 65%, went all the way to the highest switch, marked 450 volts. Many of them were visibly upset. They kept going because a calm man in a lab coat told them to.
What changed the result
Milgram ran the experiment many ways, and the differences are the useful part.
- When the man in the coat gave his orders by phone, full obedience dropped to about 21%.
- When an ordinary-looking person gave the orders, it dropped to about 20%.
- When the study moved from Yale to a plain office building, it dropped to about 48%.
The orders were the same each time. What changed was how much authority the person and the place seemed to have.
What researchers say now
Later researchers have questioned parts of the study. Some volunteers suspected the shocks were not real, and the man in the coat did not always follow his script. A milder version run in 2009 still found that most people kept going when told to. The core finding has held up: people follow the signs of authority more than they expect to.
What it sounds like at home
"My teacher said so, so it's true."
A teacher is usually right about their subject. The habit to build is asking how they know, so the answer still holds on the day the person is wrong.
"The man at the store said this is the best one."
He may know the products well. He is also paid to sell them. Ask what makes it the best.
What it sounds like online
"As a nurse, I would never give my kids this."
The job title is doing the persuading. Look for the reason or the study behind it.
"Doctors don't want you to know this."
This borrows authority and attacks it in the same sentence, and it gives no evidence either way.
How it shows up when someone is selling to you
I spent 7 years in sales, and I name the tricks. These are the common ones.
- A white coat or a set of scrubs in an advertisement.
- "Experts recommend" with no expert named.
- "Nine out of ten" of some profession, with no study you can look up.
- A title that sounds official, such as "senior specialist" or "certified consultant."
- A manager who is brought in to approve your deal.
- A real credential used for something outside that person's field.
Why it works
Following people who know more than you saves time, and most days it is the right call. The trouble is that the brain responds to the signs of authority, such as the coat, the title and the confident voice, as if they were the knowledge itself. Behavior expert Chase Hughes lists authority as one of the four things that drive human behavior in his FATE model: Focus, Authority, Tribe and Emotion.
When trusting an authority is reasonable
Trusting an expert is not the fallacy. It is reasonable to rely on a person who is an expert in the exact subject, who shows the evidence, and whose view matches what other experts in that field say. It becomes a fallacy when the authority is the only reason given.
Three questions to ask
- Is this person an expert in this exact subject?
- What is the evidence, apart from who is saying it?
- What does this person gain if I agree?
A question worth teaching kids
"How do they know?" It works on advertisements, on videos, and on adults. A kid who asks it out of habit is much harder to fool.
How I hold myself to this
I sell hair products, so this applies to me. It is why my hair photos are dated and say "No filters, no edits," and why I quote the label when I describe what a product does. You can check the claim yourself.
Try it this week
Each time you hear "experts say," or see a title used as the reason, ask one question out loud: "What is that based on?" Count how often an answer follows.
One a week, follow for the next one. The one before this was false cause: two things in a row is not a reason.
The book behind the series.
The Tuttle Twins Guide to Logical Fallacies. Written for kids. Works on adults. It's the one we pull off the shelf at our house.
Questions
Is an appeal to authority always a fallacy?
No. Relying on a real expert in their own field, who shows evidence, is reasonable. It is a fallacy when the person's status is the only support for the claim.
What did the Milgram experiment find?
In the best-known version, 65% of volunteers gave what they believed was the maximum 450-volt shock because a researcher in a lab coat told them to continue.
What is an example of appeal to authority in advertising?
An actor in a white coat recommending a product, or the phrase "experts recommend" with no expert or study named.
How do I respond to an appeal to authority?
Ask for the evidence apart from the person. "What is that based on?" is enough.

